MINUTES OF 152nd  MEETING OF NORTHERN REGIONAL COMMITTEE HELD ON 23rd  TO 25th November, 2009

 

The 152nd meeting of the Northern Regional Committee (NRC), National Council for Teacher Education (NCTE) was held from 23rd to 25th November 2009 at Jaipur. The following members and convener were present:

 
 Prof. D.N. Sansanwal Chairperson, NRC-NCTE
 Sh. S.P. Anand Member, NRC-NCTE
 Prof. M.K. Das Member, NRC-NCTE
 Prof. M.P. Sharma Member, NRC-NCTE   
Dr, K.S.Yadav, Regional Director/Convener, NRC,NCTE
 

Dr. F. U. Khan and Prof. (Ms) Bharti Baweja could not attend the meeting.

 

Dr, K.S.Yadav, Convener/ RD NRC, NCTE welcomed the Hon’ble Chairperson and members of Northern Regional Committee.

 

      With the permission of the Chairperson, Dr, K.S. Yadav, (Convener) presented the Agenda before the Committee. Agenda-wise decisions taken were as follows:-

 

AGENDA ITEM NO 152.00.00   CONFIRMATION OF THE MINUTES OF THE 151st MEETING OF NRC

 
 
SL. NO. AGENDA NO. CASE DECISION OF NRC
1 152.00 CONFIRMATION OF THE MINUTES OF 151st MEETING OF NRC. THE MINUTES OF 151st MEETING OF NRC HELD FROM 20TH to 21ST OCTOBER 2009 HAVE BEEN CONFIRMED AND UPLOADED ON THE WEBSITE OF NRC. Minutes are confirmed with following modification:  

The decision in respect of RJ-684 may be read as “Conduct inspection to verify the infrastructure facilities, instructional facilities, staff, etc.”

 

AGENDA ITEM NO 152.01.00   CONSIDERATION OF THE COURT CASE

 
S.NO. AGENDA NO. BRIEF DESCRIPTION BRIEF OF CASE     DECISION OF NRC  
    
    2
SHAHID CAPTAIN VIJAY PRATAP SINGH SMARAK DEGREE COLLEGE, VILL – JUNEDPUR, POST – SAIYADSARANWA, G.T. ROAD (ALLAHABAD KANPPUR ROAD), TEHSIL – CHAIL, KAUSHAMBI, UTTAR PRADESH, UP,  

FILE NO. – UP-2894, COURSE – B.ED.

       The institution’s application was rejected in NRC’s 135th Meeting held on 22nd – 23rd December, 2008 due to  the following reasons”-  
    1. The State Govt. Recommendation letter no. 1497/sattar-6/2008-2(268) dated 09.06.2008 was negative.
 

      After the rejection the institution filed a writ petition in the Hon’ble High Court, Allahabad, Uttar Pradesh vide writ petition no. 54264/09.

 

      The Hon’ble High Court, Allahabad, UP has passed an order with the direction to pass appropriate orders on the pending matter relating to grant of approval for running B.Ed. course in accordance with law within a period of three months from the date of production of certified copy of this order.

Hon,ble High Court, Allahabad, U.P has directed to grant approval as per law. Since from 2010 – 2011 academic session there is a ban, so recognition cannot be granted.
    3
KRISHNA COLLEGE OF EDUCATION, KHASRA NO. – 39,42, VILL – SHAHBAZPUR KHANA, POST – BIJNOR, DISTT. – BIJNOR, UP,  
 

FILE NO. UP-3313, COURSE – B.ED.

       The institutions application was rejected in NRC’s 142nd Meeting held on 22nd – 23rd December, 2008 due to  the following reasons”-  
  1. The land is on private lease for thirty years which is not as per clause 8(7) of Regulations, 2007.
  2. The submitted Building Plan is not approved by competent authority.
 

      After the rejection the institution filed a writ petition in the Hon’ble High Court, Allahabad, Uttar Pradesh vide writ petition no. 26357/09.

 

      The Hon’ble High Court, Allahabad passed an order are as follows:-

 

      The application of the petitioners for grant of recognition and permission to run B.Ed. Course has been rejected by the Northern Regional Committee, Jaipur, Rajasthan. Accordingly to the learned counsel for the petitioners both these grounds taken for rejection are contrary to the Regulations of the National Council for Teacher Education. In this regard the petitioners propose to submit a fresh representation to the Northern Regional Committee explaining how the defects stand removed. In case any such representation is submitted along with a certified copy of this order the Northern Regional Committee may consider and decide the same within a period of six weeks thereafter strictly in accordance with law.

As the land is on private lease for thirty years but as per NCTE Regulations Clause 8(7) the land could be either on ownership basis or on lease from Government / Government Institutions for a period of not less than 30 years. Hence, the application for B.Ed. programme cannot be considered.
    4
MAA SHARDA RAJNARAYAN RAI SMARAK MAHAVIDYALAYA, PALI- GHAZIPUR, UTTAR PRADESH  

FILE NO. – 2860, COURSE – B.ED.

       The institution’s application was rejected in NRC’s 135th Meeting held on 22nd – 23rd December, 2008 due to the following reasons”-  
  1. The State Govt. Recommendation letter no. 1000/sattar-6/2008-2(112) dated 15.04.2008 was negative.

 

      After the rejection the institution filed a writ petition in the Hon’ble High Court, Allahabad, Uttar Pradesh vide writ petition no. 43695/09.

 

      After hearing counsel for the parties and perusing the records it transpires that the basis for refusing to grant ‘No Objection Certificate’ by the State Govt. on the strength of Government order dated 11.02.2005 has gone as the Govt. order dated 11.02.2005 has been rescinded by the State Govt. on 01.06.2009 therefore the consequential rejection of the recognition by the NCTE requires to be considered. In view of the writ petition is disposed of with the observation that the petitioner may approach to State Govt. as well as NCTE along with certified copy of the order passed by this court with formal application before both the respondents. In case such application is filed, the State Govt. shall reconsider the matter to grant of “No Objection Certificate”. In view of the Government Order dated 01.06.2009 in accordance with law within a period of three weeks from the date of receipt of the petitioner’s application along with the certified copy of the judgment of this court and the decision taken on petitioner’s application be communicated to the NCTE within further period of two weeks and it is thereafter the respondent no. 3 shall pass appropriate order on the form of the petitioner for grant of recognition in accordance with law within a further period of three weeks from the date of receipt of the order of State Government on the petitioner’s application for grant of “No Objection Certificate”.

 It cannot be considered because the NOC to be issued by State Government has not been submitted by the Institute yet.
    5
DEEPANSHU COLLEGE OF PROFESSIONAL STUDIES, CHUNATI GADA, DELHI ROAD, DISTT.- SAHARANPUR, UP  

FILE NO. – 3145, COURSE – B.ED.

       The institution’s application was rejected in NRC’s 140th Meeting held on 25th – 26th April, 2009 due to  the following reasons”-  
      1. Application is not on the Prescribed Format.
      2. Copy of Approved Building Plan.
      3. Land Use Certificate.
      4. FDR For Rs. Five Lacs.
      5. FDR For Rs. Three Lacs.
      6. Building Completion Certificate.
 

      After the rejection the institution filed a writ petition in the Hon’ble High Court, Allahabad, Uttar Pradesh vide writ petition no. 50104/09.

 

      The Hon’ble High Court, Allahabad, UP, Considering the facts and circumstances of this case, this petition is disposed of with liberty to the petitioner to submit a fresh representation as observed above within a period of 15 days from today along with certified copy of this order and upon receipt thereof, the Northern Regional Committee, Chaired by the Regional Director of the committee, respondent no. 2 shall consider the same and pass appropriate orders within a period of two months from the date of receipt of the same in accordance with law.

 As per the Hon’ble High Court, Allahabad, UP, directions the Institution was required to submit that how the discrepancies pointed out by NRC, NCTE, Jaipur have been removed and also  submitting the relevant documents in support there of. The Institution has not submitted the same. Hence, the application cannot be considered.  
    6
IIMT COLLEGE OF EDUCATION, O-POCKET, GANGA NAGAR, NAWANA ROAD, MEERUTM UP,  

FILE NO. UP-2484, COURSE B.P.ED.

       The application institution was granted recognition on 03.07.2009 with the direction to register the land in the name of the institution within six months.  

      After the recognition the institution filed a writ petition in the Hon’ble High Court, Allahabad, Uttar Pradesh vide writ petition no. 55736/09.

 

            The Hon’ble High Court, Allahabad, UP has passed a order, the clause 11 of the order dated 03.07.2009 passed by the Regional Director of the Northern Regional Committee. National Council for Teacher Education shall remain stayed and the petitioner shall not be compelled to execute the sale deed.

      		 Stay order of Hon’ble High Court is noted.
     7        6. LORD KRISHNA COLLEGE OF EDUCATION,

VILL. &  PO. SIWANI BOLAN, DIST. HISAR, HARYANA  

HR-1731

COURSE: B.ED.

 The institution has submitted application for recognition of B.Ed. course on 21.7.2008 under section 14 of NCTE Act.   

Inspection has been conducted on 7.9.2008.

 

The recognition of the institution has been refused on 23.4.2009 as per the decision of the NRC in its 139th meeting for the following reasons :-

  • CLU is not issued by the competent authority on the prescribed format
  • In response to our letter, the State Govt recommendation is negative
 

The institution had preferred an appeal against the above decision of NRC on 22.6.09.  The appeal has also been rejected by the appellate authority and confirmed the NRC order appealed against vide their order dated 7.8.09.

 

Aggrieved by the above decision of the appellate authority the inst has filed a writ petition before the Hon’ble High Court of Delhi. The High Court has set aside the Council’s order dated 7.8.09 and remanded the matter to the Council for consideration afresh. 

The Council, as per the directions of the Hon’ble High Court, has reconsidered the matter on 4.9.09 and remanded to NRC for conducting an inspection and taking an appropriate decision thereafter vide their order dated 4.9.09.  The matter was placed before NRC in its 150th meeting.  The NRC has decided to conduct inspection.  The institution has filed a Writ petition No. 12154/2009 and.  Legal opinion was sought from the NRC counsel at Jaipur, Shri Sanjay Pareek, Advocate on the Judgment dated 22.10.09, “.. in order to avoid any serious consequences recognition may be granted and institution may be asked not to press for cost part of the judgment…”  

A Contempt petition No. 767/2009 has also been filed by the inst.

 Implement the orders of Hon’ble High Court of Delhi.
    8 7 GURUDHAM COLLEGE OF EDUCATION, KHEDAR, 6TH K.M. STONE, HISAR ROAD, NH-65, THE. BARWALA, DIST. HISAR, HARYANA  

HR-1736

COURSE : B.ED.

 The institution has submitted application for recognition of B.Ed. course on 25.7.2008 under section 14 of NCTE Act.   

The application of the institution has been closed as per the decision of NRC in its 140th meeting vide order dated 12.5.2009.

 

The institution has filed a Writ petition No. 9908 of 2009 before the Hon’ble High Court of Punjab & Haryana.  The Court has directed to reconsider the application of the petitioner for grant of recotnition in the light of Sale deed(produced efore the Court) and pass final order within four weeks vide order dated 8.7.09.

 

The institution has preferred an appeal u/s 18 of the NCT Act on 18.5.09. The appeal has been rejected and NRC’s above closer order has been confirmed by the appellate authority vide their order dated 7.8.09.

 

The institution has again filed a Writ petition No. 13802 of 2009 before the Hon’ble High Court of Punjab & Haryana. The Court has directed to pass a fresh order in the light of the directions contained in the order dated 8.7.09, needful be done within a period of two weeks from the date a certified copy is received by the competent authority. 

 

The above matter has been referred to our Legal counsel, Shri Tibrewal.  Same is placed in File for kind perusal.

 Implement the orders of Hon’ble High Court of Delhi.
    9 8 DRONACHARYA INSTITUTE OF TEACHER EDUCATION, SHIMLA BYEPASS ROAD, DHARMAWALA, VIKAS NAGAR, DEHRADUN, UTTRAKHAND

UR-25

COURSE: B.Ed.

 The institution has submitted application for recognition of B.Ed. course on 24.12.04 under section 14 of NCTE Act.   

Inspection has been conducted on 15.6.2005.

 

Recognition has been granted on 01.7.2005 for B.Ed. course with an intake of 100 w.e.f. 28.6.2005.

 

An inspection has been conducted under section 17 on 17.6.2009. 

 

The matter has been placed before NRC in its 146th meeting.  The committee has decided to withdraw recognition. 

 

The institution has filed Writ Petition No. 1626(MS) of 2009 in the Hon’ble High Court of Uttranchal.  The Court has directed that, “till next date of listing the decision taken by the respondent no 3 in its meeting dated 5-7th August 2009 shall not be given effect to.  

        List this petition in the week commencing 5th October 2009 alongwith Writ Petition 1403/2009(M/S).  in the meantime the respondents may file counter affidavit”.

 Interim Order of High Court of Uttarakhan, Nanital is noted.
 
 

AGENDA ITEM NO: 152.02.00   CONSIDERATION OF APPEAL ORDERS 

 
S.NO. AGENDA NO. NAME OF THE INSTITUTION APPEAL ORDER APPEAL DECISION DECISION OF NRC
    10
AMARDEEP COLLEGE, AMAR NAGAR, JALESAR ROAD, FIROZABAD-283203, UP  

FILE NO. – UP-1440, COURSE - BTC

 F.NO.89-1003 / 2009 / APPEAL / DATED 06.11.2009 THE APPEAL WAS ACCEPTED AND SET – ASIDE NRC’S ORDER DATED 09.07.2009 AND REMAND BACK THE CASE TO NRC FOR EXAMINATION OF THE FACULTY PROFILE AND THEREAFTER PASS APPROPRIATE ORDER.
    • As the list of Faculty submitted by the Institution pertains to 2007 which is too old to consider. Thus, the Institution is directed to submit the fresh list of Principal and Faculty dully selected as per NCTE norms for BTC / D.Ed.
 
Hence, the committee directs the Institution to submit the above mentioned document within 21 days.
11
R.D.R.B. MAHAVIDYALAYA, GRAM & POST – NATTHUPUR, LODHNA, AMBEDKAR NAGAR-224149, UP  

FILE NO. UP-1698, COURSE – BTC.

 F.NO.89-987 / 2009 / APPEAL / DATED 06.11.2009 THE APPEAL WAS ACCEPTED AND REMANDED BACK THE CASE TO NRC FOR EXAMINATION OF THE FACULTY PROFILE AND THEREAFTER PASS APPROPRIATE ORDER.
    • As the list of Faculty submitted by the Institution pertains to 2006 which is too old to consider. Thus, the Institution is directed to submit the fresh list of Principal and Faculty dully selected as per NCTE norms for BTC / D.Ed.
 
Hence, the committee directs the Institution to submit the above mentioned document within 21 days.
12
SHIVVATI SHIVNANDAN SHUKLA MAHAVIDYALAYA, ARHOLI SEIKH, PUKHRAYAN, KANPUR DEHAT, UP  

FILE NO. UP- 2526, COURSE – BTC

 F.NO.89-1035 / 2009 / APPEAL / DATED 06.11.2009 THE APPEAL WAS ACCEPTED AND REMANDED BACK TO THE NRC FOR ALLOWING EXTENSION OF TIME OF 90 DAYS FOR FULFILLING THE REQUIREMENT AS PER THE LETTER OF INTENT PRIOR TO RECOGNITION.
    • As per appeal committee decision, the Institution is directed to submit the list of Principal and Faculty appointed as per NCTE norms for D. Ed. / BTC within 90 days.
13
KISHAN INSTITUTE OF TEACHER EDUCATION, MEWLA CROSSING, NEAR AMAR UJALA, DELHI ROAD, FARTAPUR, MEERUT, UP  

FILE NO. UP- 2400, COURSE –M.Ed.

 F.NO.89-993 / 2009 / APPEAL / DATED 06.11.2009 THE APPEAL WAS ACCEPTED AND REMANDED BACK THE CASE TO NRC FOR EXAMINATION OF THE FACULTY AND THEREAFTER PASS APPROPRIATE ORDER.
    • Dr. (Ms) Renu Singh holds Ph.D in Sanskrit and MA in Education where as the facts are misrepresented in the submitted affidavit mentioning there by Ph.D. In Education and M.Ed. / MA (Education). Thus, she is not qualified as per NCTE norms for M.Ed.
    • Dr. Nempal Singh is having MA (Education), M.Sc. (Physics), B.Ed. and Ph.D. (Physics) degrees. He does not have M.Ed. degree as per NCTE norms.
    • The College has appointed two lecturers in place of three lecturers.
    • One Professor has not been appointed.
 
Hence, the committee directs the Institution to appoint teaching staff as per NCTE Norms for M.Ed. within 90 days.
14
SHRI KRISHNA COLLEGE OF EDUCATION, KHASRA NO. – 98/2, NEAR SABJI MANDI, POST – SAHAJALPUR, TEHSIL – SHIKAHABAD, DISTT. – FIROZABAD, UP  

FILE NO. UP- 3394, COURSE-B.Ed.

 F.NO.89-937 / 2009 / APPEAL / DATED 06.11.2009 THE APPEAL WAS ACCEPTED SET ASIDE NRC’S ORDER DATED 03.07.09 AND REMAND BACK THE CASE TO NRC FOR EXAMINING THE APPLICATION AND POINT OUT THE UNFILLED COLUMNS OF THE APPLICATION TO THE INSTITUTION AND TAKING FURTHER NECESSARY ACTION.
    • There are many unfilled coloums in the application form.
 
Hence, the committee directs the Institution to fill all the incomplete columns within 21 days. 
15
INTEGRAL UNIVERSITY, DASAULI, POST – BAS-HA, KUSI ROAD, LUCKNOW, UP  

FILE NO. UP – 2445, COURSE - M.Ed.

 F.NO.89- 693/ 2009 / APPEAL / DATED 11.09.2009 THE APPEAL WAS ACCEPTED AND SET – ASIDE NRC’S DECISION 14TH – 16TH JUNE, 09.  

NOW THEREFORE, THE COUNCIL HEREBY REVERSES THE ORDER APPEALED AGAINST.
    • The Faculty for M.Ed. is to be appointed as per NCTE norms for M.Ed. and documents related to experience certificate, mark sheets, affidavits on Rs. 10 and Rs 100 are to be submitted.
 
Hence, the committee directs the University to submit the above mentioned documents within 21 days.
16
MUSLIMA GIRLS DEGREE COLLEGE, SIR –SYED NAGAR, KARULA, MURADABAD, UP  

FILE NO. UP – 2176, COURSE – B.Ed. ADDL.

 F.NO.89- 546/ 2009 / APPEAL / DATED 11.09.2009 THE APPEAL WAS ACCEPTED AND SET – ASIDE NRC’S ORDER DATED 19.05.2009 AND REMAND BACK THE CASE  TO NRC FOR EXAMINATION OF THE  FILE IN TOTALITY TAKING INTO ACCOUNT THE REPLY TO THE SHOW CAUSE NOTICE AND THEREAFTER PASS APPROPRIATE ORDERS.
  • The building plan showing multipurpose hall is not approved by competent authority.
  • Documents related to qualification and experience of HOD has not been submitted.
  • Documents related to qualification of Faculty are not submitted.
  • As per norms for additional B.Ed. intake, the Institution is required to submit the accreditation certificate from NAAC. This has not been complied with.
 
Hence, the committee directs the Institution to reply within 90 days.
17
SHYAM BAKSHA SINGH MAHAVIDYALAYA, VPO- HALIA PUR, THE- MUSHAPHIRKHANA, DISTT.- SULTANPUR , UP  

FILE NO. UP – 3140, COURSE – B.Ed.

F.NO. 89 – 1065 / 2009 / APPEAL / DATED 06. 11. 2009 THE APPEAL WAS ACCEPTED AND SET – ASIDE NRC’S ORDER DATED 27.07.2009 AND REMAND BACK THE CASE  TO NRC FOR EXAMINING THE SAME ON MERIT AND TAKING FURTHER NECESSARY ACTION.
  • VT may be constituted.
18
MAA GYATRI ARYAN KANYA MAHAVIDYALAYA, TEHSIL ROAD, JALESAR, DISTRICT- ETAH, UP  

FILE NO. UP – 2487, COURSE – BTC

 F.NO. 89 – 1027 / 2009 / APPEAL / DATED 06. 11. 2009 REMANDED BACK THE CASE TO THE NRC FOR ALLOWING MORE TIME FOR SUBMISSION OF ORIGINAL DOCUMENTS REGARDING APPOINTMENT OF QUALIFIED FACULTY / STAFF AND THEREAFTER TAKING APPROPRIATE DECISION.
  • The affidavits of Rs. 100 and Rs. 10 in original have not been submitted.
 
Hence, the committee directs the Institution to submit the above mention document within 21 days.
19 10 JAIPUR NATIONAL UNIVERSITY, PLOT NO.- 108 -115, MAIN AGARA PASS, VILL- KHOREBARIYAN, JAGATPURA JAIPUR, RAJASTHAN (M.Ed. ADD. RJ- 2242) 89-649/2009-apeal The Council has accepted the appeal and remanded the case to NRC for further processing of the file for additional intake on the basis of merit. The council has reversed the order of NRC.  

Remarks of office:

The institution has submitted documents vide letter received in office on 19.11.2009
  • Dr. Vishwas saxena appointed as Reader is not qualified as per NCTE norms for M.Ed.
  • The list of appointed Faculty pertains to 2008 which is too old. Thus, the Institution is directed to submit the fresh list of appointed Faculty as per NCTE norms for M.Ed.
Hence, the committee directs the University to appoint Faculty as per NCTE norms for M.Ed.  Within 60 days.
20 11 M.J.R.P COLLEGE OF EDUCATION, N.H.-8, NEW DELHI ROAR, VIL- KANT, POST- ACHROL, DISTT- JAIPUR, RAJASTHAN (M.ED., RJ-2246) 89-767/2009-apeal The appeal has been accepted and set aside NRC’s order dated 01.06.2009 and remanded the case to NRC for causing inspection of the institution within a month of issue of this order to ascertain the availability of infrastructure and instructional facilities as per NCTE norms and thereafter pass appropriate order.
  • VT is to be constituted.
21 12 TIKA RAM GIRLS COLLEGE, SONEPAT, MISSION ROAD, SONEPAT-131001, HARYANA. (C.P.Ed.,HR- 249) 89-710/2009-apeal The appeal reversed NRC order dated 15.07.2009 with direction to the NRC to issue the recognition order under clause 7(11) of the NCTE regulation, 2007 within 15 days of issue of this order. Implement the decision of the appeal committee and issue recognition order under clause 7(11).
22 13 K.C. COLLEGE OF EDUCATION, VPO- GANAUR, TEHSIL- GANAUR, DISTT- SONEPAT, HARYANA (B.ED.,HR-1711) 89-712/2009-apeal The council reached the conclusion that there was enough ground to accept the appeal and remand the case to NRC for further processing of the file based to merits, as per NCTE regulations
  • The land is not in the name of Institution.
Hence the committee directs the Institution to register the land in the name of Institution within 90 days.
 
 

AGENDA ITEM NO.151.03.00 CONSIDERATION OF REPLY IN RESPONSE TO LETTER ISSUED ON RECEIPT OF APPEAL ORDERS

 
SL NO. AGENDA NO. NAME OF  THE INSTITUTION COURSE FILE NO. DECISION OF NRC
23 1 Haryana College of Education, Kinana, Jind, Haryana JBT HR-321 The original file of the institution, reply of the institution submitted in compliance of letter of intent issued under clause 7(9) along with all other related documents, affidavits, Act of NCTE, 1993, Regulations and Guidelines of NCTE published from time to time, etc. were considered and the committee decides to grant recognition under clause 7(11) of Regulations 2007.
 
 
 
 

AGENDA ITEM NO 152.04.00 CONSIDERATION OF THE REPLIES RECEIVED FOR CONVERSION FROM 7(9) TO 7(11)

 
S.NO. AGENDA NO.     BRIEF DESCRIPTION COURSE FILE NO.     DECISION OF NRC  
    
24.
ANAND COLLEGE OF EDUCATION, VILL & POST – JETHUWAL, BATALA ROAD, DISTT. – AMRITSAR, PUNJAB M.Ed. PB-464 The original file of the institution, reply of the institution submitted in compliance of letter of intent issued under clause 7(9) along with all other related documents, affidavits, Act of NCTE, 1993, Regulations and Guidelines of NCTE published from time to time, etc. were considered and the committee

observed that

    • Faculty has not been appointed as per NCTE norms for M.Ed.
 

Hence, the committee decides to allow the Institution to appoint Faculty within three months.

    25
AKAL COLLEGE OF EDUCATION, GURSAGAR MASTUANA SAHIB, DISTT. – SANGRUR, PUNJAB B.P.Ed. PB-314 The original file of the institution, reply of the institution submitted in compliance of letter of intent issued under clause 7(9) along with all other related documents, affidavits, Act of NCTE, 1993, Regulations and Guidelines of NCTE published from time to time, etc. were considered and the committee decides to grant recognition under clause 7(11) of Regulations 2007.
    26
GURU HAR GOVIND COLLEGE OF EDUCATION, VILL- GONDWAL (RAIKOT), DISTRICT- LUDHIANA, PUNJAB. B.Ed. PB-577 The original file of the institution, reply of the institution submitted in compliance of letter of intent issued under clause 7(9) along with all other related documents, affidavits, Act of NCTE, 1993, Regulations and Guidelines of NCTE published from time to time, etc. were considered and the committee decides to grant recognition under clause 7(11) of Regulations 2007.
    27
GYAN BHARTI INSTITUE OF MANAGEMENT & STUDIES, VILL – JAWERI, MEERUT CANT, TEHSIL – SARDHANA, MEERUT, UP B.Ed. UP-3242 The original file of the institution, reply of the institution submitted in compliance of letter of intent issued under clause 7(9) along with all other related documents, affidavits, Act of NCTE, 1993, Regulations and Guidelines of NCTE published from time to time, etc. were considered and the committee decides to grant recognition under clause 7(11) of Regulations 2007.
    28
SRI GIRRAJ MAHARAJ INSTITUTE OF MANAGEMENT, 7TH KM STONE, MATHURA – BHARATPUR HIGHWAY, VILL.-MUNDESI, POST – DHANGAON, DISTT.-MATHURA, UP B.Ed. UP-3186 The original file of the institution, reply of the institution submitted in compliance of letter of intent issued under clause 7(9) along with all other related documents, affidavits, Act of NCTE, 1993, Regulations and Guidelines of NCTE published from time to time, etc. were considered and the committee observed the following:
    • Photocopy of mark sheets and experience certificates of the appointed Faculty has not been submitted.
 

Hence, the committee decides to allow the Institution to submit the above mentioned document within 21 days.

29
MAA DRAUPDI DEVI KANYA VIDYALAYA, PL NO. 37, SHIKARPUR-JANIPUR KALAN, VILL.-JANPUR KALAN, TEHSIL SHIKARPUR, DISTT.-BULANDSHAHR, UP B.Ed. UP-2933 The original file of the institution, reply of the institution submitted in compliance of letter of intent issued under clause 7(9) along with all other related documents, affidavits, Act of NCTE, 1993, Regulations and Guidelines of NCTE published from time to time, etc. were considered and the committee observed the following:

 

    • The Faculty has not been appointed through dully constituted selection committee as per NCTE norms.
    • Affidavits on stamp paper of Rs. 100 and Rs. 10 have not been submitted.
 

Hence, the committee decides to allow the Institution to remove above mentioned deficiencies within 90 days.

  30.
CHAUDHARY CHARAN SINGH COLLEGE OF EDUCATION & TECHNOLOGY, VILL – SADARPUR, POST – MOD KHURD, TEHSIL – MAWANA, DISTT. – MEERUT, UP B.Ed. UP-3227 The original file of the institution, reply of the institution submitted in compliance of letter of intent issued under clause 7(9) along with all other related documents, affidavits, Act of NCTE, 1993, Regulations and Guidelines of NCTE published from time to time, etc. were considered and the committee observed the following:

 

    • The Faculty has not yet been appointed.
    • Affidavit by the Management on stamp paper of Rs. 100 and Rs. 10 have not been submitted.
 

Hence, the committee decides to allow the College to appoint Faculty and submit affidavits within 90 days.

   31.
KANCHAN SINGH BHOOLI DEVI MAHAVIDYALYA, KHASRA NO.-1173 & 1174, VILLL. - BHIKIHANAPUR, SHAJAHANPUR, VINAYA, POST-SARWAN KHERA, AKBARPUR, KANPUR,U.P. M.P.Ed. UP-3114 The original file of the institution, reply of the institution submitted in compliance of letter of intent issued under clause 7(9) along with all other related documents, affidavits, Act of NCTE, 1993, Regulations and Guidelines of NCTE published from time to time, etc. were considered and the committee observed the following:

 

    • Appointed Faculty does not have qualification as per NCTE norms for M.P.Ed.
    • The Website has not been developed as per NCTE norms.
 

Hence, the committee decides to allow the College to meet the above mentioned deficiencies within 90 days.

   32.
NEHRU GRAM BHARTI VISHAWAVIDYALAYA, KOTWA, JAMUNIPUR, DUBAWAL, DISTT. – ALLAHABAD, U.P. B.Ed. ADDL. UP-3548 The original file of the institution, reply of the institution submitted in compliance of letter of intent issued under clause 7(9) along with all other related documents, affidavits, Act of NCTE, 1993, Regulations and Guidelines of NCTE published from time to time, etc. were considered and the committee observed the following:

 

    • NAAC certificate has not been submitted.
    • HOD does not have qualification as per NCTE norms for B.Ed.
 

Hence, the committee decides to allow the College to meet the above mentioned deficiencies within 90 days.

   33
  1. `
OM BUDHESHWAR NATH R.S.V.S. MAHAVIDYALAYA, , VILL – TINACHITARI, POST OFFICE – SAGAR, TEHSIL – PRATAPGARH, UP B.Ed. UP-3144 The original file of the institution, reply of the institution submitted in compliance of letter of intent issued under clause 7(9) along with all other related documents, affidavits, Act of NCTE, 1993, Regulations and Guidelines of NCTE published from time to time, etc. were considered and the committee observed the following:

 

    • The Website has not been developed as per NCTE norms.
    • There is no staff to teach methods of Teaching Mathematics, Physical Science and Biological Sceince.
 

Hence, the committee decides to allow the College to meet the above mentioned deficiencies within 90 days.

   34
KET EDUCATIONAL INSTITUTE, VILL – FATIHA, FARAH, MATHURA. UP B.Ed. UP-3323 The original file of the institution, reply of the institution submitted in compliance of letter of intent issued under clause 7(9) along with all other related documents, affidavits, Act of NCTE, 1993, Regulations and Guidelines of NCTE published from time to time, etc. were considered and the committee observed the following:

 

    • The Website has not been developed as per NCTE norms.
 

Hence, the committee decides to allow the College to meet the above mentioned deficiency within 90 days.

   35
MAHATAMA JAGJEEVAN SAHAB MAHAVIDYALAYA, VILL – RAM NAGAR, TANDWA, PLOT NO. – 110, 73, DISTT. – FAIZABAD, UP B.Ed. UP-3445 The original file of the institution, reply of the institution submitted in compliance of letter of intent issued under clause 7(9) along with all other related documents, affidavits, Act of NCTE, 1993, Regulations and Guidelines of NCTE published from time to time, etc. were considered and the committee decides to grant recognition under clause 7(11) of Regulations 2007.
   36
ROHIT MEMORIAL INSTITUTE OF EDUCATION, VILL – NARSINGPUR, POST – DOSTPUR, DISTT. – SULTANPUR, UP B.Ed. UP-3416 The original file of the institution, reply of the institution submitted in compliance of letter of intent issued under clause 7(9) along with all other related documents, affidavits, Act of NCTE, 1993, Regulations and Guidelines of NCTE published from time to time, etc. were considered and the committee observed the following:  
    • The Website has not been developed as per NCTE norms.
 

Hence, the committee decides to allow the College to meet the above mentioned deficiency within 90 days.

   37
MANYAWAR KASHIRAM MAHAVIDYALAYA, CHARUHAR JIYAYAK, MAHAMAYANAGAR, PURE GOSAIN, DALMAU, RAI BAREILLY, UP B.Ed. UP-3319 The original file of the institution, reply of the institution submitted in compliance of letter of intent issued under clause 7(9) along with all other related documents, affidavits, Act of NCTE, 1993, Regulations and Guidelines of NCTE published from time to time, etc. were considered and the committee observed the following:  
    • The Website has not been developed as per NCTE norms.
    • Qualification of Dr (Ms.) Suman Lata Singh does not match with the qualification as mentioned in affidavit of Rs. 100.
 

Hence, the committee decides to allow the College to meet the above mentioned deficiencies within 90 days.

   38
SAKET GIRLS DEGREE COLLEGE, DAHILAMAN, PRATAPGARH-230001, UP B.Ed. UP-2567 The original file of the institution, reply of the institution submitted in compliance of letter of intent issued under clause 7(9) along with all other related documents, affidavits, Act of NCTE, 1993, Regulations and Guidelines of NCTE published from time to time, etc. were considered and the committee observed the following:

 

  • The appointed Faculty is not as per NCTE norms for B.Ed.
  • There is no Faculty to teach Methods of Teaching English, Geography, Economics and Commerce.
  • Faculty has not been appointed on permanent basis.
  • The Website has not been developed as per NCTE norms.
 

Hence, the committee decides to allow the College to meet the above mentioned deficiencies within 90 days.

   39
SHRI PARAMHANS SHIKSHAN PRASHIKSHAN MAHAVIDYALAYA, VILL – JAISINGPUR, POST – AYODHYA, FAIZABAD, UP B.Ed. UP-2854 The original file of the institution, reply of the institution submitted in compliance of letter of intent issued under clause 7(9) along with all other related documents, affidavits, Act of NCTE, 1993, Regulations and Guidelines of NCTE published from time to time, etc. were considered and the committee observed the following:

 

    • The Website has not been developed as per NCTE norms.
    • The experience of the appointed Principal as given in affidavit does not match with the documents.
 

Hence, the committee decides to allow the College to meet the above mentioned deficiencies within 90 days.

    40
NAVYUG MAHILA SHIKSHA PRASHIKSHAN MAHAVIDYALAYA, VILL- RATANPUR – BARI SAHIJAN, POST OFFICE, KUNDA  BHAIROPUR, KADIPUR, SULTANPUR, UP B.Ed. UP-2964 The original file of the institution, reply of the institution submitted in compliance of letter of intent issued under clause 7(9) along with all other related documents, affidavits, Act of NCTE, 1993, Regulations and Guidelines of NCTE published from time to time, etc. were considered and the committee observed the following:

 

    • The Faculty was appointed in 2008 when the B.Ed. course was not running.
 

Hence, the committee directs the Institution to make fresh appointments and submit the relevant documents of the appointed Faculty within 90 days.

   41
S.S. EDUCATIONAL INSTITUTE, VILL-GAMARI, POST-MALPURA, DISTT.-AGRA, UP B.Ed. UP-3070 The original file of the institution, reply of the institution submitted in compliance of letter of intent issued under clause 7(9) along with all other related documents, affidavits, Act of NCTE, 1993, Regulations and Guidelines of NCTE published from time to time, etc. were considered and the committee decides to grant recognition under clause 7(11) of Regulations 2007.
   42
SHRI DARSHNA MAHAVIDYALAYA, KAKHUTOO, TEHSIL & DISTT.- AURAIYA, UP B.Ed. UP-3555 The original file of the institution, reply of the institution submitted in compliance of letter of intent issued under clause 7(9) along with all other related documents, affidavits, Act of NCTE, 1993, Regulations and Guidelines of NCTE published from time to time, etc. were considered and the committee decides to grant recognition under clause 7(11) of Regulations 2007.
    43
G.S. DEGREE COLLEGE, VILL – JAMDEEH, POST OFFICE-LABANAPAR, DISTT. – BASTI, UP B.Ed. UP-3035 The original file of the institution, reply of the institution submitted in compliance of letter of intent issued under clause 7(9) along with all other related documents, affidavits, Act of NCTE, 1993, Regulations and Guidelines of NCTE published from time to time, etc. were considered and the committee observed the following:

 

    • There is no Faculty to teach Methods of Teaching Commerce, Hindi, English, Sanskrit, Commerce and Geography.
    • Affidavit on stamp paper of Rs. 100 for appointed faculty has not been submitted.
    • Affidavit on stamp paper of Rs. 10 from the appointed Faculty has not been submitted in original.
    • The Website has not been developed as per NCTE norms.

     

Hence, the committee decides to allow the College to meet the above mentioned deficiencies within 90 days.

   44
SHRI RAM CHANDRA SINGH MAHAVIDYALAYA, VILL – LAHATI SARAIYA, POST – RUDAULI, PLOT NO. – 1244, 1245, DISTT. – FAIZABAD, UP B.Ed. UP-3500 The original file of the institution, reply of the institution submitted in compliance of letter of intent issued under clause 7(9) along with all other related documents, affidavits, Act of NCTE, 1993, Regulations and Guidelines of NCTE published from time to time, etc. were considered and the committee observed the following:

 

    • The Website has not been developed as per NCTE norms.
 

Hence, the committee decides to allow the College to meet the above mentioned deficiency within 90 days.

   45
SHRI RAMANAND KAILASH CHANDRA PAIGORIA DEGREE COLLEGE, KHASRA NO. 229, 223, 227 & 228, TEHSIL - BAH, DISTT. - AGRA, UP B.Ed. UP-3384 The original file of the institution, reply of the institution submitted in compliance of letter of intent issued under clause 7(9) along with all other related documents, affidavits, Act of NCTE, 1993, Regulations and Guidelines of NCTE published from time to time, etc. were considered and the committee observed the following:

 

    • The appointed Principal does not have teaching experience as per NCTE norms for B.Ed.
 

Hence, the committee decides to allow the College to meet the above mentioned deficiency within 90 days.

   46
NIRMAL GANGA INSTITUTE OF EDUCATION, VILL - JARGAWAN, TEHSIL – DIWAI, DISTT. - BULANDSHAHAR, UP B.Ed. UP-3071 The original file of the institution, reply of the institution submitted in compliance of letter of intent issued under clause 7(9) along with all other related documents, affidavits, Act of NCTE, 1993, Regulations and Guidelines of NCTE published from time to time, etc. were considered and the committee decides to grant recognition under clause 7(11) of Regulations 2007.
  47
SHRI MAHESH PRASAD DEGREE COLLEGE, VILLAGE – BINDAWA, POST – MOHANLALGANJ, DISTT. – LUCKNOW, U.P. B.Ed. UP-3234 The original file of the institution, reply of the institution submitted in compliance of letter of intent issued under clause 7(9) along with all other related documents, affidavits, Act of NCTE, 1993, Regulations and Guidelines of NCTE published from time to time, etc. were considered and the committee observed the following:

 

    • There is no Faculty to teach Methods of Teaching Mathematics and Physical Science.
 

Hence, the committee decides to allow the College to meet the above mentioned deficiency within 90 days.

   48
CHARAK INSTITUTE OF EDUCATION, VILL.-MAURA, POST.-CHOWK, DISTT.-LUCKNOW, UP B.Ed. UP-3080 The original file of the institution, reply of the institution submitted in compliance of letter of intent issued under clause 7(9) along with all other related documents, affidavits, Act of NCTE, 1993, Regulations and Guidelines of NCTE published from time to time, etc. were considered and the committee observed the following:  
    • Faculty has not been appointed as per NCTE norms for B.Ed.
 

Hence, the committee decides to allow the College to meet the above mentioned deficiency within 90 days.

   49
ALLAHABAD AGRICULTURAL INSTITUTE, (DEEMED UNIVERSITY), ALLAHABAD, UP M.Ed. UP-921 The original file of the institution, reply of the institution submitted in compliance of letter of intent issued under clause 7(9) along with all other related documents, affidavits, Act of NCTE, 1993, Regulations and Guidelines of NCTE published from time to time, etc. were considered and the committee observed the following:

 

    • Dr. N. Stephen does not have teaching experience as per NCTE norms for M.Ed.
    • Ms. A. Chitamani, Ms. Nidhi Srivastava, and Mr. S.H. Qasin do not possess qualification as per NCTE norms for M.Ed.
 

Hence, the committee decides to allow the College to meet the above mentioned deficiencies within 90 days.

  50
MANNIYA KANSHI RAM COLLEGE OF EDUCATION, VILL – NETA NAGAR, POST – ANOOPSHAHAR, DISTT. – BULANDSHAHAR, UP B.Ed. UP-3041 The original file of the institution, reply of the institution submitted in compliance of letter of intent issued under clause 7(9) along with all other related documents, affidavits, Act of NCTE, 1993, Regulations and Guidelines of NCTE published from time to time, etc. were considered and the committee observed the following:

 

    • The information given on affidavit of Rs. 100 is incomplete.
    • The percentage of marks at B.Ed. of Mr. Rajiv Kumar Vashishtha is less than 55 % as required.
 

Hence, the committee decides to allow the College to meet the above mentioned deficiencies within 90 days.

   51
RAJIV GANDHI MAHILA  MAHAVIDYALAYA, VILLAGE – PARDAHA, TEHSIL -  MAUNATH BHANJAN, DISTT. – MAU, U.P. B.Ed. UP-3124 The original file of the institution, reply of the institution submitted in compliance of letter of intent issued under clause 7(9) along with all other related documents, affidavits, Act of NCTE, 1993, Regulations and Guidelines of NCTE published from time to time, etc. were considered and the committee observed the following:

 

    • As indicated in affidavit on stamp paper of Rs. 100, there is no Faculty to teach Methods of Teaching English, Geography, History, Mathematics and Physical Science.
 

Hence, the committee decides to allow the College to meet the above mentioned deficiency within 90 days.

   52
MAJOR SHIV DAYAL SINGH MAHILA MAHAVIDYALAYA, VPO- MOHAMMADABAD, FARRUKHABAD, U.P. B.Ed. UP-3129 The original file of the institution, reply of the institution submitted in compliance of letter of intent issued under clause 7(9) along with all other related documents, affidavits, Act of NCTE, 1993, Regulations and Guidelines of NCTE published from time to time, etc. were considered and the committee decides to grant recognition under clause 7(11) of Regulations 2007.
    53
SW MAHADEV SMARAK MAHILA MAHAVIDYALAYA, KHASRA NO. – 22, VILL – HUSEPUR, POST – SAURIKH, DISTT, – KANNAUJH, UP M.Ed. UP-3340 The original file of the institution, reply of the institution submitted in compliance of letter of intent issued under clause 7(9) along with all other related documents, affidavits, Act of NCTE, 1993, Regulations and Guidelines of NCTE published from time to time, etc. were considered and the committee observed the following:

 

 
    • Dr. Kamla Gupta appointed as Reader has 49.04 % at M.Ed. as against 50% required. Hence she is not qualified.
    • Proceeding of staff selection committee has not been submitted.
 

Hence, the committee decides to allow the College to meet the above mentioned deficiencies within 90 days.

   54
MAA  SHEETLA DEVI TRIYUGI NARAYAN MAHILA MAHAVIDYALAYA,  VILLAGE & POST OFFICE – BARANDA, TEHSIL – BILHAUR, DISTT. – KANPUR NAGAR, U.P. B.Ed. UP-3357 The original file of the institution, reply of the institution submitted in compliance of letter of intent issued under clause 7(9) along with all other related documents, affidavits, Act of NCTE, 1993, Regulations and Guidelines of NCTE published from time to time, etc. were considered and the committee observed the following:

 

    • There is no Faculty to teach Methods of Teaching Mathematics.
    • The Website has not been developed as per NCTE norms.
    • Attested copies of experience certificate, mark sheets & degree in respect of Shri Sudhindra Kumar Singh are not submitted.
 

Hence, the committee decides to allow the College to meet the above mentioned deficiencies within 90 days.

   55
M.R. DAV COLLEGE OF EDUCATION, 5th KM STONE, SONEPAT ROAD, DISTT- ROHTAK, HARYANA M.Ed. HR- 1835 The original file of the institution, reply of the institution submitted in compliance of letter of intent issued under clause 7(9) along with all other related documents, affidavits, Act of NCTE, 1993, Regulations and Guidelines of NCTE published from time to time, etc. were considered and the committee decides to grant recognition under clause 7(11) of Regulations 2007.
    56
B.P.S. COLLEGE OF EDUCATION, BEHROR RAOD, NEAR GOVT. COLLEGE, NANGAL CHOUDHARY, THE- NARNAUL, DISTT- MOHINDERGARH, HARYANA B.Ed. HR- 1735 The original file of the institution, reply of the institution submitted in compliance of letter of intent issued under clause 7(9) along with all other related documents, affidavits, Act of NCTE, 1993, Regulations and Guidelines of NCTE published from time to time, etc. were considered and the committee observed the following:

 

  • The selection of teaching staff is not as per NCTE norms for B.Ed.
  • The selection procedure is not as per the Norms of NCTE since the subject experts mentioned in the affidavit have not signed any where.
  • The qualification of the appointed Principal Mr. Patel Ramji Bhai given in the affidavit does not match with the qualification given in the attached list. Further, the percentage at M.Sc. (Chemistry) is 47.44 % which less than the required percentage.
  • According to affidavit the appointed Principal is not having Ph.D. Degree while as per the attached list Principal has been awarded Ph.D. degree.
  • The teaching experience certificate of Principal is not attached.
  • Marks of Mr. Bhup Singh Yogi appointed as lecturer given in the affidavit do not match with the marks given in attached list.
 

Hence, the committee decides to issue Show Cause Notice on above mentioned points and directs the Institution to reply within 21 days.

  57
BLUE MOUNTAINS COLLEGE OF TEACHER EDUCATION, DOHRAN KHAS, KANDOLI, DEHRADUN, UTTRAKHAND B.Ed. UR- 182 The original file of the institution, reply of the institution submitted in compliance of letter of intent issued under clause 7(9) along with all other related documents, affidavits, Act of NCTE, 1993, Regulations and Guidelines of NCTE published from time to time, etc. were considered and the committee observed the following:

 

  • The Faculty is to be appointed as per NCTE norms for B.Ed. within three months.
 

  Hence the committee directs the Institution to appoint Faculty within three months as per NCTE norms for B.Ed.

 
 

AGENDA ITEM NO.152.04.01  CONSIDERATION OF THE REPLY UNDER SECTION 14(3) (B) OF NCTE ACT 1993

 
 
SL NO. AGENDA NO. NAME OF  THE INSTITUTION COURSE FILE NO. DECISION OF NRC
58. 1. SHAHEED BHAGAT MAHILA B.ED. COLLEGE, JHOTWAR ROAD, KHATIPURA, JAIPUR, RAJASTHAN(Shifting case) B.Ed. RJ- 669 VT should be sent for verification of infrastructural facilities, labs etc.
59. 2. KOTHARI TEACHER TRAINING COLLEGE, SANKHANTAL, THE- RAJGARH, CHURU, DISTT- CHURU, RAJASTHAN

(Shifting case)

 B.Ed. RJ- 559 VT should be sent for verification of infrastructural facilities, labs etc.
60. 3. UNITED COLLEGE OF EDUCATION, VPO- KAUL, DISTT- KAIRTHAL, HARYANA B.Ed.

ADD

 HR- 1269 The original  file of  the institution, reply received from the institution along with all other related documents, Act of  NCTE, 1993,  Regulations  and Guidelines of NCTE published  from time to time were considered by the committee and the committee observes the following:

 

  • The land is still in the name of society.
  • NAAC certificate has not been submitted.
 

Hence, the committee decides to directs the Institution to submit the above mentioned documents within 90 days.

61. 4. RAMDEO SHIKSAHK PRASHIKSHAN MAHAVIDYALAYA, BARMER ROAD, JAISALMER, RAJASTHAN(Shifting case) B.ED. RJ- 515 VT should be sent for verification of infrastructural facilities, labs etc.
62 5 SAVITREE BAI PUBLIC SHIKSHAK PRASHIKSHAN MAHAVIDYALAY, VILL- NEAR DAULATPUR, JAIPUR, RAJASTHAN

(Shifting case)

 B.Ed. RJ- 496 VT should be sent for verification of infrastructural facilities, labs etc.
 
 

(DR.K.S.YADAV)           (D.N. Sansanwal)